The return of Amaia Montero to La Oreja de Van Gogh is being one of the most commented musical events of the year. The band has returned to the stage with the 'Tantas cosas que contar' tour, with which they celebrate their 30-year career and are managing to fill venues throughout Spain. However, the public's success coexists with a controversy that has pursued the singer since she resumed her position as vocalist: the videos of some moments of her performances that are spread on social networks and that have fueled criticism about her voice, her physique, and her way of performing on stage.

The artist has decided to speak out about this situation in an interview on 'Hoy por Hoy', on Cadena SER, along with her bandmates. Montero has not hidden that the comments are affecting her and has explained that, although she tries to stay out of it, it is difficult when each concert puts her back in the center of conversations. "I am suffering a lot. In some way you suffer, there are many of us involved in this tour. And they are saying a lot of nonsense and that generates suffering, frustration," she admitted.
The singer has also responded directly to those who question her vocal ability based on fragments of her live performances. "I have seen what is circulating and what is circulating are errors. Errors that are made on a stage and anywhere. But that is not the whole concert," she defended. For Montero, these videos do not reflect the complete experience of those who come to see her or the work behind each performance.
TikTok videos versus a sold-out tour
Since Amaia Montero returned to lead La Oreja de Van Gogh, social media has become a showcase for both the most celebrated moments of the tour and her occasional mistakes. On TikTok, some users have shared recordings of off-key notes, stumbles, or specific moments where the singer seems to be having difficulties. These fragments have accumulated comments and reactions, to the point that the artist herself has admitted that she has ended up seeing some of that content.
The problem, as she explained, is that a few seconds of a performance can end up overshadowing a concert of several hours. "That's not the whole concert," she insisted. Her bandmate Álvaro Fuentes also argued that a live show cannot be judged solely by a recording made with a mobile phone, often with limited sound and image quality. In his opinion, these videos do not necessarily represent what the audience who was there experienced. The band's response also comes at a time when the tour is being very well received. The band has sold out tickets for their concerts and its members have highlighted the emotion of reuniting with several generations of fans. In the interview, Amaia recalled that behind the show there are more than 150 people working and claimed the collective effort: "We leave our lives in every damn gig." She also downplayed any stumbles that may occur during a performance: "And if one day I fall, well, I fell."
Amaia Montero has been showing an evolution on stage since her return to La Oreja de Van Gogh, improving performance after performance and gaining confidence as the tour progresses. Focusing solely on a specific failure means ignoring the journey the singer is making and the effort behind each live show. Because, although social media allows any error to be shown, it should also serve to recognize progress and not turn every stumble into the summary of an entire career.
The criticism has not been limited to her voice either. The artist has received comments about her physical appearance and her wardrobe, a pressure she has addressed forcefully. In another interview granted to 'El País', Montero responded to comments about her weight: "I don't care if they call me fat, because I am fat. I'll lose weight when I feel like it". The singer explained that the stress and anxiety that accompanied the first stages of the tour also had consequences in her daily life.
Amaia's recovery and the impact of criticism
The controversy takes on another dimension if one considers the personal stage the singer has gone through. In her conversation with 'El País', Montero spoke openly about the most difficult years of her life and how she managed to return to music after a period in which she was away from the stage for a long time. "When you get out of hell, when you spend seven years in bed, when you've been admitted to a psychiatric hospital, when you've wanted to leave this world twice because you see nothing beyond... And, suddenly, I overcome it, and overcoming it is amazing", she recounted.
In this context, psychologist Lara Ferreiro has analyzed in 'SEMANA' magazine the impact that constant criticism can have on the artist's self-esteem. The specialist reminds us that recovering does not mean ceasing to suffer from difficulties, but rather developing tools so that comments and complicated moments do not end up destroying personal confidence. She also focuses on the aesthetic pressure and ageism that many well-known women suffer, especially when their physique becomes the subject of public debate.
Meanwhile, La Oreja de Van Gogh continues with its musical commitments. The tour will continue during 2027 with performances in Spain and America, and the group has announced that they already have eight or nine songs underway for a new album. They have also announced their next international concert at the Royal Albert Hall in London. A musical future that contrasts with the noise surrounding the singer on social media: while venues continue to fill up, some users continue to focus on videos of a few seconds.
Contact