The Provincial Court of Barcelona has maintained the provisional imprisonment of Jonathan Andic, avoidable under a one million euro bail, and has rejected his defense's appeal. The Ninth Section has thus confirmed the order issued by the Martorell Court of First Instance within the framework of the Mossos d'Esquadra investigation into the death of Isak Andic Ermay.
The resolution was adopted by a majority of two votes to one and is signed by magistrate Neus Codina Mendoza. The president of the chamber, Andrés Salcedo Velasco, has presented a dissenting opinion in which he argues that the measure should have been revoked.
The chamber maintains imprisonment, but admits that accidental fall is still on the table
The court maintains the precautionary measures already agreed upon by Judge Raquel Nieto: withdrawal of passport, prohibition from leaving national territory, and weekly appearance before the court. The resolution also explains that the analysis was delayed for several months because the three magistrates could not review all the material provided by the parties, including videos, audios, and expert reports, until mid-September.
The majority expressly recognizes that the hypothesis of an accidental fall "retains elements of plausibility and cannot be considered excluded." It also admits that the technical reports from the mountain intervention unit did not determine a push, struggle, or intervention by a third party, nor did they find traces linking the investigated person to a violent act.
Although it considers some of the evidence valued by the instructing judge to be secondary, such as the family and economic context, the forced footprint at the point of the fall, and the disappearance of the phone, the chamber understands that there are indeed "sufficient reasons" to provisionally sustain a possible participation. This judgment is based on the coincidence of several facts: the fall occurred at the only exposed point of a route that the investigated person knew, his explanations about the separation and about what he saw and heard clash with the victim's phone records and with the visibility measurements, and the call to 112 occurred about eight minutes later.
The court insists that this reasoning does not equate to proving the incriminating hypothesis nor does it alter the presumption of innocence. It also values that Jonathan Andic has remained located, has attended judicial summonses, and has returned to Spain after his travels, although it does not completely eliminate the risk of flight.
The dissenting opinion questions whether the evidence is sufficient to sustain preventive detention
Salcedo Velasco disagrees with the majority decision. In his opinion, the chamber's own order weakens practically all the elements that the court had treated as evidence, and this review is not compensated by a mere reference to the joint assessment.
The magistrate argues that the evidence may serve to sustain an investigation, but it does not reach the necessary intensity to justify provisional imprisonment. For this reason, he would have partially upheld the defense's appeal and would have revoked the imprisonment, while maintaining the withdrawal of the passport, the prohibition from leaving Spain, and the weekly appearances.
The majority, on the other hand, maintains the measure due to the seriousness of the expected penalty, the change in procedural status after the formal indictment on May 19, and the economic capacity and international ties of the investigated person. For now, the case remains open and the precautionary measures remain in force while the investigation progresses.
Contact