The Constitutional Court decides this Tuesday whether to admit for processing the appeal for protection presented by the Ombudsman against the suspension of the right to vote of naturalized persons by the Democratic Memory Law, known as the 'grandchildren's law', a resolution that, for now, does not delve into the full merits of the conflict, but it does oblige the high court to rule on a decisive point: whether it formally studies the appeal and what it does with the urgent request to lift the suspension immediately.
The issue has reached the Plenary after the Fourth Section unanimously agreed to elevate the matter due to its relevance. Along with the admission of the appeal, the Constitutional Court must also rule on the very urgent precautionary measures requested by the Ombudsman, who asks that these people be able to vote in the general elections on November 29 without waiting for a definitive resolution.
The suspension affects 163,020 people
The origin of the case lies in the decision of the Supreme Court to maintain the precautionary suspension of the vote of those naturalized by the grandchildren's law. This measure affects 163,020 people, who will not be able to exercise their right to vote unless consular offices certify that they are descendants of exiles.
The legal debate now revolves, above all, around whether the appeal reaches the Constitutional Court too soon. A report by the court's own lawyers considers it "premature" to admit it because, in their opinion, the ordinary judicial process would not yet be exhausted.
The argument of the lawyers and the open procedure in the Supreme Court
According to this criterion, the Supreme Court maintains an open period for allegations and, therefore, must still rule again on the precautionary measures adopted in September and later confirmed in October. This scenario places the Constitutional Court before an immediate dilemma, because it can reject or postpone admission, understanding that the procedure is still alive in the Supreme Court, or it can open the door to urgently review the electoral exclusion of those affected before 29N.
This decision will determine whether the case continues only in the Supreme Court or if it also becomes a constitutional battle over the scope of the right to vote of persons naturalized by the Democratic Memory Law.
Contact